Decision No. 50/2026
Determining the commencement date of the first term of office of the National Human Rights Commission, including the Committee for the Prevention of Torture
Published in Official Gazette No. 50 of 19 November 2026, pp. 4905–4908.
The Board of the National Human Rights Commission, including the Committee for the Prevention of Torture,
Having regard to Law No. 62 of 27 October 2016 establishing the National Human Rights Commission, including the Committee for the Prevention of Torture, as amended, in particular Articles 2, 7, 28, 30 and 31 thereof,
Having regard to Law No. 273 of 7 March 2022 amending Law No. 62/2016, in particular its provisions amending Articles 28 and 30,
Having regard to Decree No. 3267 of 19 June 2018 constituting the National Human Rights Commission, including the Committee for the Prevention of Torture,
Having regard to Decree No. 5147 of 5 July 2019 constituting the National Committee for the Prevention of Torture, in particular Article 2 thereof, which provides that the Committee’s term ends when the Commission’s term ends,
Having regard to Decree No. 1762 of 7 November 2025 concerning the Commission’s Internal Rules, in particular Articles 8, 9 and 68 thereof,
Having regard to Decree No. 1763 of 7 November 2025 concerning the Commission’s Financial Regulations,
Having regard to Decree No. 3777 of 1 September 2026 concerning the Commission’s Code of Ethics, published in Official Gazette No. 40 of 10 September 2026,
Having regard to Law No. 40 of 10 February 2026 on the 2026 State Budget, published in Official Gazette No. 7 of the same date, and to the schedules annexed thereto concerning the Commission’s budget,
Having reviewed the draft decree establishing the fixed monthly remuneration of the President, Vice-President and members of the Commission, prepared by the Ministry of Justice and included as item 4 on the agenda of Council of Ministers meeting No. 50, held on 6 February 2026, on which a decision was deferred at the request of the Minister of Finance,
Having also reviewed the Ministry of Finance’s observations of 17 December 2025, in particular on the proposed amounts, and the opinion of the State Council of 13 January 2026, which stressed that the remuneration should be commensurate with the Commission’s workload, responsibilities and duties, taking into account the salaries and allowances paid by the Lebanese State in the prevailing economic circumstances,
Having reviewed the Commission’s detailed budget for 2026, filed with the Department of the General Budget and Expenditure Control at the Ministry of Finance, the appropriations approved for the Commission under the State Budget Law, and the Treasurer’s statement, accounting records, payment orders and transfer records relating to the monthly remuneration paid and the basis for its disbursement,
Having reviewed a copy of the accreditation file submitted to the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions in early October 2026, the information it contains on the commencement date of the term, and the correspondence concerning its consideration by the Sub-Committee on Accreditation at its April 2027 session,
Having placed the determination of the commencement date of the first term on the agenda of the Board meeting held on Friday, 6 November 2026, duly convened the meeting, verified that the statutory quorum was met, and deliberated on the facts, documents and legal grounds set out below,
Grounds for the Decision
I. Applicable legal provisions
- Article 30(b) of Law No. 62/2016, added by Law No. 273/2022, makes the commencement of the first term contingent on the issuance of all decrees governing the Commission. Article 30(a) provides that the fixed monthly remuneration of the President, Vice-President and members of the Commission is to be set by a decree adopted by the Council of Ministers on the proposal of the Minister of Justice.
- Article 68 of the Internal Rules confirms the exceptional and foundational nature of this arrangement. It must therefore be interpreted in conjunction with the provisions of the law establishing the Commission, so as to fulfil its purpose while respecting its wording and giving it effect.
- Deferring the date from which the first term is calculated is intended to provide the regulatory framework necessary for the Commission to operate and to ensure that the term is not used up while the Commission awaits adoption of the basic rules it needs to exercise its powers effectively and independently.
II. Completion of the basic regulatory framework
- The Internal Rules and Financial Regulations were issued under Decrees Nos. 1762 and 1763 of 7 November 2025. The Code of Ethics was subsequently issued under Decree No. 3777 of 1 September 2026 and published on 10 September 2026. This completed the basic framework governing the Commission’s operations, financial administration, standards of conduct and accountability.
- The Board considers that implementing decrees that may be required at a later stage, including those concerning staffing structures, recruitment and contracting, should not leave the commencement of the term pending indefinitely. For this purpose, the foundational rules needed for the Commission to begin operating must be distinguished from the implementing measures required as its work develops.
- According to the documents before the Board, the decree establishing fixed monthly remuneration had yet to be issued as at the date of this Decision, although the draft had been placed on the agenda of the Council of Ministers. The Board therefore considered the effect of this delay on the date from which the term is calculated.
III. Effect of the State Budget Law and payment of remuneration
- A global appropriation for salaries and wages in the budget is insufficient, in itself, to establish that the monthly remuneration of the President, Vice-President and members has been determined. Bank transfers alone likewise do not establish the legal basis for entitlement.
- Assessing the financial effect of the budget requires reading the appropriations approved for the Commission, the detailed budget prepared on that basis, the budget execution decisions and payment orders together. These documents show how the amounts were estimated, allocated and disbursed, with due regard to the respective legal force of each document.
- On the basis of the documents annexed to this Decision, the Board found that the detailed budget specifies annual allocations according to each member’s position and that remuneration is paid monthly from the Commission’s account at Banque du Liban to the beneficiaries’ bank accounts, in accordance with the approved payment orders and accounting records.
- The hierarchy of legal norms requires that a legislative provision in force be given effect in matters it directly governs. That principle does not confer legislative force on every document used to prepare the budget. Nor can the State Budget Law be deemed to replace the remuneration decree merely because an appropriation has been made or payments have been made regularly.
- Taking account of the detailed budget, the approved appropriations and their execution leaves the obligation to issue the remuneration decree in place and preserves the annual character of the budgetary arrangement. These elements provide a basis for assessing the extent to which the decree’s financial purpose has been fulfilled solely for the purpose of interpreting the condition governing the commencement of the first term.
IV. Significance of the detailed budget and limits on reliance on case law
- The Commission’s detailed budget for 2026 was filed with the Department of the General Budget and Expenditure Control at the Ministry of Finance and served as the basis for including the Commission’s appropriations in the State Budget. On pages numbered 5 and 6, under item 13, “Allocations, Salaries, Wages and Related Payments”, and its first subheading, “Allocations and Salaries under the Draft Budget Law”, the detailed budget specifies separate annual amounts for the President, Vice-President, Secretary-General, Treasurer and remaining members.
- The total 2026 appropriation under the contribution item for salaries and wages, earmarked to cover the annual allocations of the Commission’s ten members, is twenty-seven billion nine hundred million Lebanese pounds (LBP 27,900,000,000). This corresponds to LBP 256,800,000 per month for the President and LBP 229,800,000 per month for each of the nine other members.
The breakdown by position and the amount of the annual appropriation provide a specific financial record for estimating the cost of members’ remuneration. They also make it possible to trace the relationship between the budget prepared by the Commission and the appropriations entered for it in the State Budget. The detailed budget thus identifies both the beneficiaries and the amounts allocated to them.
- Constitutional case law on budget laws, including Constitutional Council Decision No. 3/2024 of 4 April 2024, distinguishes between financial provisions directly related to budget execution and regulatory provisions that do not properly belong in a budget law. That distinction helps define the scope of the financial effect of the approved appropriations. It does not constitute a decisive precedent for interpreting the conditions governing the commencement of the Commission’s term or for treating the detailed budget as a substitute for the decree required by law.
The Board’s interpretation rests on four elements taken together: the allocation of specific annual amounts to the President, Vice-President and members in the detailed budget filed with the Ministry of Finance, the inclusion of appropriations on that basis in the State Budget, the monthly payment of remuneration in accordance with the accounting records, and the completion of the foundational rules through the issuance and publication of the Code of Ethics.
For the purpose of determining when the first term began, the Board considers that these elements support the interpretation that the financial purpose of the remuneration decree has been achieved in practice through the annual budget and its execution. Under that interpretation, once the foundational rules were in place, the continued delay in issuing the decree did not justify further postponing the date from which the term is calculated. This is the Board’s interpretation. The matter remains open to judicial determination, and the appropriation alone does not automatically produce this result.
The obligation to issue the remuneration decree remains in force, and the budgetary arrangement remains annual. The competent courts retain jurisdiction to review the legality of the disbursements and the interpretation of the condition governing the commencement of the term. Issuing the decree remains necessary to place the Commission’s financial arrangements on a stable footing.
V. Commencement date and its effects
- In light of the above, the Board considers that using 10 September 2026, the date on which the decree concerning the Code of Ethics was published, provides a public and definite date for the completion of the basic regulatory framework. Under the interpretation adopted in this Decision, the annual appropriations and their execution, as described above, allow the term to begin despite the delay in issuing the remuneration decree.
- Communicating this interpretation to the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions records the Commission’s stated institutional position, which must be documented and reflected consistently in the information the Commission provides. The communication itself does not establish a domestic legal basis for the commencement of the term.
- Determining when the first term began does not constitute a new appointment or a renewal of membership. The statutory non-renewable term of six years continues to apply, and the Commission’s existence and exercise of its powers before that date are unaffected.
The Board therefore decides as follows
Article 1 — Interpretation of the provisions governing the commencement of the first term
For the purpose of organising the Commission’s work and determining the particulars of its first term, the Board interprets Article 30(b) of Law No. 62/2016 on the basis that the foundational rules governing the Commission’s operation are complete. In accordance with the documents annexed to this Decision, the Board also takes into account the annual allocations specified in the Commission’s detailed budget, the inclusion of appropriations on that basis in the State Budget, and the monthly payment of remuneration. The Board considers that these elements, taken together, fulfil the financial purpose of the remuneration decree within the annual budget framework.
Article 2 — Commencement date of the term
10 September 2026, the date on which Decree No. 3777 concerning the Commission’s Code of Ethics was published in the Official Gazette, is designated as the date from which the first term of the Commission constituted under Decree No. 3267 of 19 June 2018 is calculated.
This determination applies to the members of the National Committee for the Prevention of Torture appointed under Decree No. 5147 of 5 July 2019, in accordance with the provision that the Committee’s term ends when the Commission’s term ends.
The term remains six years and is non-renewable, in accordance with the law.
Article 3 — Scope of the Decision
This Decision records the Board’s interpretation of the provisions in force. It does not establish a new term, renew the membership of any member, or amend the law establishing the Commission or its regulations.
It does not affect the legal effects of acts performed by the Commission or the Committee before the date specified in Article 2, determine any prior financial entitlements, or create any retroactive entitlement to remuneration, differences in pay or other financial rights.
Article 4 — Issuance of the remuneration decree
The Board affirms the need to issue without delay the decree establishing the fixed monthly remuneration of the President, Vice-President and members of the Commission, in order to place its financial arrangements on a stable footing beyond the annual arrangements under budget laws.
The President of the Commission shall follow up on this matter with the Presidency of the Council of Ministers and the Ministries of Justice and Finance.
Article 5 — Documentation of the financial basis
The following documents shall be annexed to this Decision and retained in its file:
- A certified copy of the schedules annexed to the State Budget Law concerning the Commission’s appropriations.
- A copy of the detailed budget filed with the Ministry of Finance, accompanied by a breakdown of the annual allocations for the Commission’s ten members and a reconciliation of their total with the corresponding appropriation.
- A copy of the correspondence concerning the Commission’s accreditation file and the commencement date of the term communicated in that file.
Article 6 — Notification and follow-up
The President of the Commission shall notify the Presidency of the Council of Ministers and the Ministries of Justice and Finance of this Decision.
The Commissioner for International Relations shall submit the Decision to the Secretariat of the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions for inclusion in the accreditation file scheduled for consideration in April 2027 and shall indicate that it reflects the interpretation adopted by the Board.
Article 7 — Registration and publication
This Decision shall be entered in the register of Board decisions. The minutes of the meeting shall record the names of those present, confirmation that the quorum was met, a summary of the deliberations, the voting result, and any reservations or dissenting opinions.
This Decision shall apply to the organisation of the Commission’s work from the date of its adoption. It shall be published in the Official Gazette and on the Commission’s website and communicated where necessary.
Beirut, 6 November 2026
هذه المقالة متاحة أيضًا بـ:




